Friday, April 5, 2013

Moral Dilemmas

1. Sacrificing the lives of the few to save the lives of the many is often assumed to be a higher level of moral reasoning.  What can you say about it? (Film: Swordfish)

2. A man’s wife is pregnant, her health goes south quickly. The doctor’s tell the man he must choose between his wife and his unborn child. He must sign a paper allowing the doctors to abort his baby and save his wife, or he must take his chances, and possibly both the wife and the baby could die. In one instance the husband wants desperately to abort the baby, because in his reasoning, he only has one wife, and without her he can’t have any other babies. If they abort this baby, they can always have another one. The doctors wants to save both the wife and the baby, and risk accidentally killing both. The husband refuses to sign papers allowing his baby to be aborted. He decides to take his chances, and the doctor’s were able to save both his wife and his new baby girl.

3.
Organ transplantation in Japan is regulated by the 1997 Organ Transplant Law which legalized organ procurement from "brain dead" donors.After an early involvement in organ transplantation that was on a par with developments in the rest of the world, attitudes in Japan altered after a transplant by Dr. Wada in 1968 failed, and a subsequent ban on cadaveric organ donation lasted thirty years. The first transplant after the Organ Transplant Law had defined "brain death" took place in February 1999.
Due to cultural reasons and a relative distrust of western medicine, the rate of organ donation in Japan is significantly lower than in Western countries.